Related Video

The Legal Lineup

More than 140 businesses, advocacy groups and government officials have gotten involved in challenges to the major climate rules finalized by EPA under the Obama administration. Click here for a list of the specific cases in which groups have gotten involved, and what position they have taken.

read read list

Featured Story

CLIMATE: It's red states vs. blue in legal war over EPA rules (Greenwire, 10/12/2010)

With climate legislation stalled in Congress and U.S. EPA just months away from regulating greenhouse gases for the first time, 37 states have taken sides in a court battle that could end up steering U.S. climate policy for years.

Just like the cap-and-trade bills that narrowly cleared the House and floundered in the Senate, challenges to the Obama administration's climate program have highlighted a bitter divide between industry-heavy states and their environment-minded counterparts. All of them are now lined up for a high-stakes legal showdown that will allow a few federal judges to decide what 535 members of Congress have not.

The states involved in the litigation are closely divided. Seventeen are asking to review EPA regulations, while 20 are supporting one or more EPA rules, according to a Greenwire analysis of federal court records. Thirteen states have not taken a side.

Pat Parenteau, an environmental law professor at Vermont Law School, said he cannot think of any environmental case that has gotten so much attention from the states. Just more than 20 states got involved in Massachusetts v. EPA, the 2007 case in which the Supreme Court ruled that EPA had to consider regulating greenhouse gases under the Clean Air Act.

One reason is that the political stars have aligned to make environmental regulations a hot-button issue on the campaign trail, Parenteau said. And while the Supreme Court's 2007 decision had huge implications for the states, "the stakes are higher here," he said. "After all, we are talking about all of the major economic sectors being affected by these regulations."

Though it is only in the preliminary phase, the court battle is already daunting in terms of paperwork. About 90 legal challenges to the climate program have been filed so far, drawing filings from more than 140 businesses, trade groups, advocacy groups and lawmakers.

Lawmakers were warned about this scenario, experts say.

Rep. John Dingell (D-Mich.), one of the architects of the Clean Air Act, often told his colleagues that if they did not reach an agreement, the climate debate would become a "glorious mess" of regulations and litigation. That is where things are headed now, said Eric Pooley, the deputy editor of Bloomberg BusinessWeek, during a Washington, D.C., panel discussion last week on the future of U.S. climate policy.

readRead the full story

Position on EPA's Climate Rules by State

 

In this exclusive analysis of federal court records, E&E breaks down the positions of all 50 states in the high-stakes legal battle over the Obama administration’s climate rules. Click on a state for details on the state’s role in various court cases, as well as data on greenhouse gas emissions, leadership and other factors that could be contributing to their decisions.

Map Key

 For
 Against
 N/A

Role Abbreviations

R = Reporting Rule
E = Endangerment Finding
J = Johnson Memo
A = Auto Rule
T = Tailoring Rule

Related Stories

  12/20/2012

CLIMATE: Appeals court declines to rehear GHG-rule challenge, tees up case for Supreme Court

iconGreenwire
  09/21/2012

CLIMATE: Appeals court ends Alaskan village's federal common law fight

iconGreenwire
  09/20/2012

LAW: Lawyers go west as climate litigation warms up

iconGreenwire
  08/13/2012

CLIMATE: Industry groups seek court rehearing over GHG regulations

iconGreenwire
  06/27/2012

CLIMATE: Few legal options for losers in EPA rule challenge

iconGreenwire
  06/27/2012

LITIGATION: Appeals court gives EPA a big win on greenhouse gas rules

iconClimateWire
  06/27/2012

CLIMATE: Ball in Congress' court after greenhouse gas ruling

iconE&E Daily
  06/26/2012

CLIMATE: Appeals court upholds EPA emission rules

iconGreenwire
  06/26/2012

CLIMATE: Court knocks down industry talking points

iconGreenwire
  06/20/2012

CLIMATE: Appeals court OKs Calif.'s cap-and-trade program

iconGreenwire
  06/15/2012

CALIFORNIA: Utilities, enviros intervene to defend offset use

iconGreenwire
  06/15/2012

CLIMATE: Court decision on EPA carbon rules expected soon

iconGreenwire
  06/06/2012

CLIMATE: N.J.'s Christie sued over decision to scrap regional trading system

iconGreenwire
  03/09/2012

CLIMATE: Double setback on Va. attorney general's climate science docket

iconGreenwire
  03/05/2012

POLITICS: Va. high court denies demand for climate scientist's documents

iconClimateWire
  03/02/2012

CLIMATE: Legal wrangling continues over Calif. fuel standard

iconE&ENews PM
  03/02/2012

CLIMATE: Court rules against attorney general in UVA documents case

iconGreenwire
  03/02/2012

CLIMATE: Lawyers mull possible outcomes in greenhouse gas cases

iconGreenwire
  02/29/2012

CLIMATE: Judges' questions put heat on EPA, rule challengers

iconGreenwire
  02/29/2012

LITIGATION: The legal odyssey to curb greenhouse gases opens a new chapter on a warm February day

iconClimateWire
  02/28/2012

CLIMATE: Judges sharply question critics of EPA's greenhouse gas rules

iconGreenwire
  02/27/2012

CLIMATE: Lawyers descend en masse for arguments on greenhouse gas rules

iconGreenwire
  01/30/2012

CLIMATE: Va. Supreme Court to rehear case on insurance for global warming damage

iconGreenwire
  01/25/2012

SCIENCE: Nonprofit group to help defend scientists facing legal actions

iconClimateWire
  01/16/2012

CLIMATE: Court rejects attempt to cite EPA IG report in filing

iconGreenwire
  01/03/2012

CLIMATE: Judge blocks Calif. clean-fuel rule

iconGreenwire
  11/02/2011

CLIMATE: Court allows scientist Mann to participate in emails case

iconGreenwire
  10/17/2011

ENDANGERED SPECIES: Enviro groups want White House to re-evaluate polar bear climate rule

iconE&ENews PM
  10/14/2011

CLIMATE: Plaintiffs give EPA 2 more weeks for setting emissions timeline

iconE&ENews PM
  10/03/2011

CLIMATE: Plaintiffs fire warning shot on power plant standards for greenhouse gases

iconGreenwire
  09/16/2011

CLIMATE: Emissions rule is legal, EPA tells court

iconE&ENews PM
  09/16/2011

CLIMATE: Va. court rules that insurance doesn't cover global warming claims

iconGreenwire
  09/14/2011

SUPREME COURT: Victorious lawyer in climate case still critical of plaintiffs' strategy

iconGreenwire
  09/06/2011

CLIMATE: European enviro group backs EPA in court battle

iconE&ENews PM
  08/18/2011

CLIMATE: EPA makes case for 'endangerment' decision in federal court

iconE&ENews PM
  08/15/2011

CLIMATE: Wyo. challenge to EPA emission rules is sent to D.C. court

iconE&ENews PM
  08/15/2011

CLIMATE: Enviros sue EPA for sparing biomass from emissions rules

iconE&ENews PM
  08/09/2011

CLIMATE: Lawyers make insurance claim in bid to prove damages

iconGreenwire
  06/28/2011

CLIMATE: New lawsuit aims to pull N.Y. out of RGGI

iconGreenwire
  06/22/2011

SUPREME COURT: Businesses rank climate ruling among term's biggest victories

iconGreenwire
  06/21/2011

CLIMATE: Briefs filed in next phase of EPA rules challenge

iconGreenwire
  06/21/2011

CLIMATE: Impact of Supreme Court emissions ruling likely to be felt in other cases

iconGreenwire
  06/20/2011

CLIMATE: High court blocks states' lawsuit over coal plant emissions

iconGreenwire
  06/06/2011

EPA: Briefs filed in tailpipe-rule litigation

iconGreenwire
  05/31/2011

EPA: Supporters of endangerment challenge file opening briefs

iconGreenwire
  05/23/2011

CLIMATE: Challengers fire opening shots in 'endangerment' legal battle

iconGreenwire
  04/19/2011

CLIMATE: States' 'nuisance' argument seems to fall on deaf ears in Supreme Court

iconGreenwire
  03/23/2011

CLIMATE: Court sets schedule for litigation over EPA emission rules

iconGreenwire
  02/15/2011

CLIMATE: Wyo. joins Texas in suing EPA over regulatory rollout

iconGreenwire
  02/01/2011

CLIMATE: Ariz. attorney general breaks silence on withdrawal from EPA case

iconE&ENews PM
  01/12/2011

CLIMATE: Court signs off on EPA takeover of Texas permitting

iconE&ENews PM
  01/18/2011

CLIMATE: EPA, Calif. defend waiver for state's tailpipe standards

iconE&ENews PM
  12/14/2010

CLIMATE: Court order on GHG rules provides comfort to industry challengers

iconGreenwire
  12/10/2010

CLIMATE: Court rejects bid to block EPA greenhouse gas rules

iconE&ENews PM
  12/07/2010

CLIMATE: Upcoming ruling on EPA regs could affect Supreme Court 'nuisance' case

iconGreenwire
  12/06/2010

CLIMATE: High court takes up 'nuisance' case

iconGreenwire
  12/03/2010

CLIMATE: Sotomayor recusal likely as Supreme Court weighs 'nuisance' case

iconGreenwire
  11/12/2010

CLIMATE: Legal high fliers flock to EPA litigation

iconGreenwire
  11/02/2010

LITIGATION: States, enviro groups urge court to let EPA climate rules proceed

iconGreenwire
  10/29/2010

CLIMATE: Obama admin urges court not to freeze EPA rules

iconE&ENews PM
  09/16/2010

CLIMATE: 3 filings offer previews of legal attack on EPA regs

iconGreenwire
  09/13/2010

CLIMATE: Even page limits are disputed in litigation over EPA regs

iconGreenwire
  08/25/2010

CLIMATE: Obama admin urges Supreme Court to vacate 'nuisance' ruling

iconGreenwire
  08/04/2010

CLIMATE: Utilities ask Supreme Court to decide if GHGs are a 'nuisance'

iconE&ENews PM
  07/29/2010

CLIMATE: EPA rejects 10 'endangerment' challenges

iconE&ENews PM
  06/14/2010

CLIMATE: Enviro groups sue EPA over nonroad vehicle emissions

iconE&ENews PM
  06/01/2010

CLIMATE: Court tosses landmark global warming ruling after late recusal

iconGreenwire
  03/19/2010

CLIMATE: States take sides in 'endangerment' legal brawl

iconGreenwire
  12/15/2009

CLIMATE: EPA notice sets stage for regulation writing, lawsuits

iconGreenwire
  10/19/2009

CLIMATE: Courts follow landmark 2nd Circuit ruling with 2 GHG decisions

iconGreenwire
  09/21/2009

CLIMATE: Federal court approves long-stalled nuisance lawsuit against power companies

iconGreenwire
  01/14/2009

CLIMATE: Obama's early agenda linked to court rulings -- Jackson

iconE&ENews PM
  04/02/2007

CLIMATE: Supreme Court orders EPA to consider regulating greenhouse gases

iconGreenwire