Dems cite climate concerns to probe insurers’ use of credit scores

By Amelia Davidson | 08/04/2026 06:05 AM EDT

House and Senate Democrats are looking for more data on how home insurers calculate their pricing.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren.

Senate Banking ranking member Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts is leading Democrats from both chambers in asking insurance companies about their policies for setting rates. Allison Robbert/AP

House and Senate Democrats are asking insurance companies how they use credit scores in setting rates, noting particular concerns as climate-related wildfires and severe weather affect premiums.

Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs ranking member Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and Rep. Ayanna Pressley (D-Mass.) led 18 colleagues in questioning six insurance companies: USAA, State Farm, Progressive, Liberty Mutual, Farmers and Allstate.

The lawmakers accused the insurers of using homeowners’ credit history to spike rates — something banned in three states. The Democrats said the practice is “particularly concerning” as insurance rates skyrocket, in part due to worsening natural disasters caused by climate change.

Advertisement

They also said insurers have at times tried to justify rate hikes by nodding to climate-related disasters alone — and in doing so, have concealed the role that other financial factors, like integrating credit scores, have played in rate decisions.