Judge appears unlikely to revive youth EPA climate lawsuit

By Lesley Clark | 10/01/2024 06:25 AM EDT

A federal judge in California warned of a “very, very, very uphill” climb for young activists seeking to sue the agency for falling short on climate action.

Twelve of the 18 young climate activists behind the Genesis v. EPA lawsuit.

Twelve of the young climate activists behind the Genesis v. EPA lawsuit. Robin Loznak/Courtesy of Our Children’s Trust

Attorneys for a group of young California climate activists on Monday urged a skeptical federal judge to revive their lawsuit against EPA, arguing that the agency is discriminating against youth.

Oral arguments before Judge Michael Fitzgerald of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California followed his May decision that scrapped the young activists’ lawsuit — but gave them one more opportunity to revise their complaint.

Fitzgerald, who said in May that the California youth lacked standing to bring their lawsuit because their complaints could not be fixed by a court, opened Monday’s hearing by saying he had “yet to be convinced” that the judicial system could help the challengers.

Advertisement

“It really is a very, very, very uphill problem that you have,” Fitzgerald, an Obama appointee, told attorneys with Our Children’s Trust, the Oregon-based law firm which represents the young activists.

GET FULL ACCESS