2 climate hawks face off over N.Y. House seat

By Adam Aton | 06/10/2020 07:07 AM EDT

A primary race in New York features two Democrats who support the Green New Deal. The challenger, Jamaal Bowman, has criticized his opponent, Rep. Eliot Engel, as not doing enough for the environment.

Jamaal Bowman (left) is challenging Rep. Eliot Engel in a Democratic primary race in New York's 16th District.

Jamaal Bowman (left) is challenging Rep. Eliot Engel in a Democratic primary race in New York's 16th District. @JamaalBowmanNY/Twitter; Francis Chung/E&E News (Engel)

Rep. Eliot Engel stood a few steps behind Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez last year as progressive Democrats unveiled their resolution for a Green New Deal.

Engel, a 16-term lawmaker from the Bronx who had just become chairman of the Foreign Affairs Committee, joined a few other Democratic heavyweights at the press conference as Ocasio-Cortez touted the resolution’s "broad support across the party."

Sixteen months later, Engel is fighting for his political life as advocates of the Green New Deal — including Ocasio-Cortez — line up behind his main primary challenger, former middle school principal Jamaal Bowman.


Progressives see New York’s 16th District primary as one of their few remaining chances to redeem an election cycle full of disappointments. Activists are framing the primary as a demonstration of their organizing muscle in the pandemic era, along with Senate primaries in Colorado and Kentucky.

But it also poses another challenge. While other races have featured a clear ideological clash between establishment-backed centrists and activist-friendly progressives, this time the lines are more blurred. Both Engel and Bowman support the Green New Deal. Engel has also co-sponsored bills establishing "Medicare for All," a major litmus test on the left.

As a result, the race is testing the boundaries of what it means to be a climate hawk — and often in personal terms.

The League of Conservation Voters’ latest scorecard gave Engel a perfect 100%, but his opponents have pointed to some of his positions under the Obama and George W. Bush administrations to suggest Engel’s climate credentials are superficial. His critics have also sought to tie him to polluting industries beyond the oil, gas and coal sectors.

In last week’s 16th District debate, Bowman said ending fossil fuel subsidies isn’t enough. The Department of Defense accounts for most of the U.S. government’s emissions, so the military budget needs to shrink, too, he said, suggesting that Engel has undercut climate policy with his hawkish foreign policy record.

"The military is one of the largest contributors to the climate emergency we’re currently living in, and Eliot Engel continues to … support weapon manufacturers because he’s funded by some of the largest weapons manufacturers in this country," Bowman said.

Engel — whose campaign declined to answer questions from E&E News — responded during the debate that he’s sought to cut off weapons sales to Saudi Arabia.

Activists have also tried to convert Engel’s support for the Green New Deal into a liability.

Jennifer Scarlott, a coordinator with North Bronx Racial Justice, accused Engel of signing onto the Green New Deal resolution only after five climate organizations announced a February rally outside his office.

"For me, this was too little too late," Scarlott wrote in The Riverdale Press, a weekly newspaper in Engel’s district.

Likewise, the Sunrise Movement has characterized Engel’s support for the Green New Deal as too tepid.

"Engel may have signed onto the resolution, but we need someone who’s willing to make the case for it," Sunrise co-founder Varshini Prakash said in a statement.

"When Republicans attacked the Green New Deal last year, Engel was silent," she said.

That dynamic emerged during last week’s debate, when Engel was given the chance to talk about his support for the Green New Deal.

After noting he co-sponsored the resolution, Engel quickly moved on to talking about House Democrats’ more moderate climate bill, H.R. 9, which would keep the United States in the Paris climate agreement.

"While we’re talking about the environment, I’m chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee. The only bill that was passed by the House to do something positive in terms of the environment was H.R. 9, which would force the United States back into the Paris Agreement," he said.

"That’s why I’ve gotten the support of all the environmental groups, because they rate me very, very high, in the high 90s if not 100, so I’ve been a fighter for the environment all these years," he said.

Indeed, the New York League of Conservation Voters and the Sierra Club endorsed Engel’s reelection, as did House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.), who noted that Engel wields unusual clout as both a committee chairman and a senior member of the Energy and Commerce Committee.

"That wouldn’t happen again. That’s a lot of power," she said last week.

Engel’s long history as a foreign policy figure has given his critics ammunition. Their complaints reach back to 2004, when Engel urged President George W. Bush to pressure OPEC nations to boost oil production as a way to lower gasoline prices.

And in 2013 and 2014, Engel was praising the growth of U.S. oil production as a counterweight to Russian and Venezuelan influence.

Those policy points have taken a back seat, though, to more personal questions in the race.

Engel, who calls himself a lifelong resident of the Bronx, had already faced criticism in 2009 for listing his Maryland home as his primary address and seeking a tax break granted to Maryland residents.

Earlier this year, as the coronavirus pandemic was sending the United States into lockdown, an Atlantic journalist found Engel at home in Maryland. Engel initially said he’d been splitting his time between the Capitol and his New York district, but his staff later contradicted him and said he hadn’t returned to New York for more than a month.

Last week, as anger spread nationwide over police violence, Engel attended a protest where an open microphone captured him saying he "wouldn’t care" about speaking at the event if he wasn’t facing a primary.

Shortly after that, Alessandra Biaggi, a New York state senator whose grandfather preceded Engel in Congress, retracted her endorsement of Engel to support Bowman.

Bowman also received endorsements from Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and Ocasio-Cortez, whose own primary upset over Joe Crowley, a top House Democrat accused of growing distant from his district, has progressives dreaming of Bowman delivering a similar victory.

That’s an expectation that Bowman has acknowledged.

"Love my sister @AOC," he tweeted in response to the comparison, "but I’m just gonna try to be Jamaal."