California housing groups join effort to weaken consumer advocates

By Saqib Rahim | 10/01/2025 06:21 AM EDT

They are supporting the state insurance commissioner’s effort to make it harder for advocates to try to block insurance rate hikes.

Carmen Balber of Consumer Watchdog in California speaks at an event in 2016.

Carmen Balber of Consumer Watchdog in California speaks at an event in 2016. State housing groups are supporting an effort that would weaken Consumer Watchdog's influence over property insurance rates. Dan Steinberg/AP Images for AIDS Healthcare Foundation

California’s property-insurance crisis is often framed as a tug-of-war between consumer groups that want to keep premiums low and insurance companies that want hikes to reflect the state’s rising risk to climate change.

But a third group recently entered the battle: California’s powerful housing lobby.

Last week, trade associations representing home builders and property owners came out in support of recent action by Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara to reduce the influence of consumer-advocacy groups they blame for disrupting insurance markets.

Advertisement

Insurers say the inability to get timely rate increases deters them from operating in California, resulting in less competition and higher premiums.

GET FULL ACCESS