Climate-smart farming no savior for crop yields, study finds

By Marc Heller | 05/23/2025 01:42 PM EDT

Researchers at Cornell University said “regenerative” agriculture practices can help the climate or boost crop productivity — but often not both.

A farmer spreads pesticide on a field

A farmer spreads pesticide on a field in Centreville, Maryland, on April 25, 2022. Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images

Farming practices that help save carbon in the soil don’t necessarily boost crop yields and sometimes make them worse, researchers said in a new study.

Researchers at Cornell University said plowing fields less and planting cover crops can actually sacrifice yields even as they offer climate benefits, adding a wrinkle to debates about how federal policies should promote the practices.

“Context matters,” said one of the lead researchers, Shelby McClelland, a postdoctoral researcher at New York University who participated in the study while working at Cornell’s College of Agriculture and Life Sciences.

Advertisement

The bottom line, McClelland said: The “win-win” scenario some groups promote for regenerative agriculture is more elusive than some might admit and highly dependent on location and other factors. Benefits for climate and crop yields “are not a universal outcome,” McClelland told POLITICO’s E&E News.

GET FULL ACCESS