Court upholds New Jersey’s landmark environmental justice rule

By Ry Rivard | 01/05/2026 04:15 PM EST

It’s unclear if the industrial groups that are fighting the rule will keep fighting in court.

The Passaic Valley Sewerage Authority plant is seen.

This Jan. 11, 2022, photo shows part of the Passaic Valley Sewerage Authority plant in Newark, New Jersey. Wayne Parry/AP

A New Jersey appeals court on Monday upheld the state’s first-of-its-kind rule to keep pollution out of low-income areas and communities of color.

The victory for the state keeps in place a 2023 rule package crafted by the Department of Environmental Protection to make it harder for eight different industries, including power plant developers, to get permits in places now considered “overburdened.”

In 2020, the Legislature approved a landmark “environmental justice” law but left a lot of decisions about how to interpret it up to rulemaking officials in Gov. Phil Murphy’s administration. Industrial groups challenged the subsequent rule by arguing DEP officials overstepped lawmakers’ intent.

Advertisement

Among the most controversial parts of the rule was Murphy officials saying they did not consider job creation and economic activity a “compelling public interest” that would allow developers to jump hurdles and get their projects green-lighted.

GET FULL ACCESS