EPA dodges clampdown with first-ever air deposition standards

By Sean Reilly | 12/11/2024 01:26 PM EST

The landmark review of ecosystem impacts of atmospheric pollutants failed to meet an independent advisory panel’s recommendations.

A flock of geese fly past a smokestack at a coal power plant.

A flock of geese fly past a smokestack at a coal power plant near Emmett, Kansas, in January 2009. EPA released air deposition standards for ecosystem impacts of pollution from sulfur oxides, nitrogen oxides and fine particles. Charlie Riedel/AP

EPA for the first time has set air quality standards geared to protecting ecosystems from the impact of pollutant deposition, but the final rule falls well short of an independent advisory panel’s majority recommendations.

The rule, posted online Wednesday morning following a lengthy review, bundles together three classes of pollutants — sulfur oxides (SOx), nitrogen oxides (NOx) and fine particles — whose fallout can harm crops, trees and aquatic life.

But while the rule revamps the SOx secondary standard from a three-hour average of 500 parts per billion to a yearly threshold of 10 ppb, it makes no change to the comparable limits for NOx and particles.

Advertisement

The 10 ppb SOx limit is in line with the recommendations of the Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee, a group of independent experts. Most members of the panel last year, however, had endorsed significant cuts in the benchmarks for the other two pollutants as well.

GET FULL ACCESS