EPA poised to confront Supreme Court concerns over smog plan

By Sean Reilly | 11/27/2024 01:25 PM EST

The do-over of the “good neighbor” rule follows objections raised in a high court ruling.

Emissions rise from smokestacks.

Emissions rise from smokestacks. EPA's "good neighbor" smog control rule has faced a series of legal setbacks. Charlie Riedel/AP

EPA is set to release a reworked justification for its “good neighbor” smog control plan aimed at addressing objections that led to a Supreme Court stay.

The White House regulations office Tuesday completed a routine review of what EPA has elsewhere dubbed a “supplemental final action,” according to a notice posted on a government tracking website. An agency spokesperson had no immediate information Wednesday on when the supplement will be made public.

EPA had sought the do-over in August, two months after the Supreme Court, in a 5-4 decision, had stayed the good neighbor plan on the grounds that agency officials had not reasonably explained how its requirements would work if covering fewer states than first anticipated.

Advertisement

The high court issued the decision via its emergency — or shadow — docket even as lawsuits challenging the plan continue to play out before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. In asking the D.C. Circuit for a chance to address the high court majority’s concern, attorneys for the agency wrote that “it would be most efficient to address that possible error now.”

GET FULL ACCESS