In Ohio primary, Mandel vs. Vance is a test of Trump’s power

By Timothy Cama | 05/02/2022 07:00 AM EDT

J.D. Vance won the former president’s support for the Senate. Several congressional districts have competitive primaries. Indiana is also holding primaries.

Donald Trump and JD Vance.

Former President Donald Trump and Ohio Republican Senate candidate J.D. Vance during an April rally. Drew Angerer/Getty Images

The closely watched Ohio Senate primary will come to a close this week, in a test of former President Donald Trump’s power in the Republican Party.

Voters will pick Republican and Democratic candidates tomorrow to face off in the November election to succeed Sen. Rob Portman (R). The race is seen as competitive by both parties and could decide the majority of the Senate, which is currently tied 50 to 50.

The leading competitors in the GOP contest are author and venture capitalist J.D. Vance and former Ohio Treasurer Josh Mandel.


Both have focused their campaigns on appealing to Trump and his supporters. They have put significant effort into airing false allegations of widespread fraud in the 2020 presidential election and hold staunchly conservative positions on issues like gender and race.

“We need to send people to Washington, D.C., who are going to fight,” Vance said in a debate last month.

“Fight against the big corporations that are destroying our values, fight against the bureaucracies that make it hard for people to live their lives, fight against the Biden administration, which has opened our border to a flood of illegal people and illegal drugs,” Vance said. “It is time to send people who know what time it is. That’s me.”

Mandel has similar rhetoric.

“When I get to Washington, I will not only be the worst nightmare of the radical left, the Democrats, Schumer, Pelosi and Biden,” he said at the debate, referring to Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.). “But I will be the worst nightmare of these weak, wimpy, squishy, [Republican-in-name-only] Republicans in Washington as well.”

Mandel led in polling throughout much of the race. But Trump endorsed Vance last month, vaulting him into the lead in subsequent polls.

“He’s tough, he’s smart, he’s a former Marine, he’s a Yale-educated lawyer … he’s a fearless [Make America Great Again] fighter, he fights like crazy, he loves Ohio and frankly, he’s a great guy,” Trump said at an Ohio rally last month. “I want to pick someone that’s going to win, and this guy is going to win.”

Both candidates have used high fuel prices to push a message that the United States should encourage more fossil fuel production, transportation and use.

“You need to open up the Keystone XL pipeline, because that will mean more oil and gas coming into our country from a country, by the way, Canada, which is an environmentally conscious country, instead of Iran, Venezuela, Russia, all of the garbage countries that Joe Biden wants to go to for oil,” Vance said at a debate, going on to slam anti-fossil-fuel corporate shareholder proposals.

“We should be drilling for all the oil and gas we can here in America,” Mandel said. “In fact, if you took the state of Ohio, the state of West Virginia and the state of Pennsylvania, our three states, and combined them into a region, that region would be the third-largest producer of natural gas in the world.

“So instead of depending on radical Muslim countries like Saudi Arabia, instead of depending on thugs like Putin in Russia, we should be depending on ourselves — Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, America — drill for oil and gas here to bring down the costs for senior citizens on fixed incomes and for families throughout our state.”

The primary has frequently been tense, with the candidates trading allegations of disloyalty to Trump and support for centrist or Democratic policies. One March forum almost devolved into a fight between Mandel and investment banker Mike Gibbons, when Mandel accused Gibbons of not being Republican enough.

Apart from Gibbons, the other major candidates in the primary are former Republican Party of Ohio Chair Jane Timken and state Sen. Matt Dolan.

In the Democratic primary, Rep. Tim Ryan is expected to easily win the nomination against progressive attorney Morgan Harper.

Ohio 9th District

In the redistricting process, Ohio’s Republican state lawmakers sought to draw as many GOP districts as possible through gerrymandering. One potential victim of that will be Rep. Marcy Kaptur (D), who chairs the Energy-Water Appropriations Subcommittee.

Kaptur is currently in a reliably Democratic district. But the 9th was redrawn to slightly favor Republicans.

Kaptur has no primary challenger. But the GOP will be picking its candidate to go up against her in November.

The main candidates in the Republican race are state Sen. Theresa Gavarone, Air Force veteran J.R. Majewski and state Rep. Craig Riedel.

Ohio 11th District

Rep. Shontel Brown (D), who won a special election last year to succeed Housing and Urban Development Secretary Marcia Fudge, is facing a rematch against former state Sen. Nina Turner.

The primary is once again a battle between the major constituencies of the Democratic Party. Turner was co-chair of Sen. Bernie Sanders’ 2020 presidential campaign, while Brown has the backing of major Democratic figures like President Joe Biden and House Majority Whip James Clyburn (D-S.C.).

“We need leaders like Shontel to help continue the fight to respond to this pandemic, lower costs for working families, and rebuild the middle class,” Biden said last week in endorsing Brown, following his endorsement last year.

Ohio 13th District

The new 13th District, centered in Akron, shares the same number as Ryan’s constituency, but includes portions of the 16th District, currently held by departing Rep. Anthony Gonzalez (R), as well as the 11th and others.

In a crowded GOP primary, Madison Gesiotto Gilbert, a conservative commentator, has earned Trump’s coveted endorsement. Other competitors include former congressional staffer Shay Hawkins and attorney Greg Wheeler.


In the 9th District, Rep. Trey Hollingsworth (R) isn’t running for reelection. Nine Republicans are vying to succeed him in the reliably GOP district.

Army veteran Stu Barnes-Israel, former state Sen. Erin Houchin and trucking company owner Mike Sodrel are the leaders in fundraising in the race.

Sen. Todd Young (R) is up for reelection this year. He has no challenger in the primary, nor does Democrat Thomas McDermott, the mayor of Hammond.