Judge backs state agency in Florida springs rule challenge

By Bruce Ritchie | 05/06/2025 12:26 PM EDT

The Florida Springs Council argued that the Department of Environmental Protection’s rules will not protect springs, which environmentalists say are being harmed by overpumping.

A person snorkels in the Rock Springs Run at Kelly Park in Apopka, Florida.

Ira Meslar explores the Rock Springs Run at Kelly Park in Apopka, Florida, on March 10, 2015. Rock Springs is a natural free-flowing spring that maintains an average flow of 26,000 gallons of water per minute and a constant temperature of 68 degrees Fahrenheit John Raoux/AP

TALLAHASSEE, Florida — An administrative law judge sided with the Florida Department of Environmental Protection on Monday in a challenge to a springs rule adopted earlier this year.

Details: Judge Gary Early said the rules defining prohibited groundwater pumping that is “harmful” to springs and rivers “are not an invalid exercise of delegated legislative authority.”

The Florida Springs Council argued the DEP rules will not protect springs, which environmentalists say already are being harmed by overpumping. Early wrote in his final order that how the rules may be applied was not a subject for his review.

Advertisement

DEP chose to apply the 2016 state law directing it to issue the rules “narrowly — but literally,” Early wrote. “Its decision was in the bounds of reason, and was not error.”

GET FULL ACCESS