Judge won’t dismiss lawsuit to block higher flood insurance rates

By Thomas Frank | 04/02/2024 06:22 AM EDT

A Louisiana federal judge allowed a suit by 10 states against FEMA to proceed but declined for now to block the new premiums.

Bill Provensal carries his shoes through the streets of New Orleans on Sept. 3, 2011, while wading through floodwaters caused by Tropical Storm Lee.

Bill Provensal carries his shoes through the streets of New Orleans on Sept. 3, 2011, while wading through floodwaters caused by Tropical Storm Lee. Bill Haber/AP

A judge has rejected the government’s request to throw out a lawsuit that seeks to block large premium hikes on millions of federal flood insurance policies.

The ruling by a federal judge in New Orleans means that a lawsuit filed by 10 Republican attorneys general challenging premium hikes could go to trial, although the judge urged the two sides to “engage in settlement negotiations.”

The Louisiana-led lawsuit is the most significant threat to the government’s recent move incorporating climate change into flood risk calculations. Premiums are slated to rise for more than 3 million policies, with some annual rates increasing by as much as $7,000.

Advertisement

Judge Darrel Papillion gave the government a partial victory in his ruling Thursday by denying the states’ request to halt the premium hikes immediately.

GET FULL ACCESS