Rushed rollback of EU green farming rules triggers dismay

By Bartosz Brzeziński, Paula Andrés | 04/24/2024 01:07 PM EDT

The bloc’s notoriously complex legislative process can apparently be simplified — when it comes to farmers, that is, and when an election is around the corner.

A farmer sprays chemicals to treat his wheat fields.

The European Commission took mere weeks to draft the proposal, working at the behest of national authorities and consulting only with farmers who are subject to the rules. Remy Gabalda/AFP via Getty Images

The EU is not known for drafting laws in haste.

But with farmers taking to the streets this spring to protest red tape, police being pelted with eggs and manure dumped on city streets, policymakers have suddenly discovered a way to speed things up — even if it means forgoing public debate or ignoring evidence that what’s being proposed will do more good than harm.

On Wednesday, lawmakers in the European Parliament are expected to rubber-stamp a proposal by the European Commission to dilute several requirements in the bloc’s €300 billion-plus farm subsidy system in an effort to reduce red tape. The requirements — known in EU jargon as “conditionality” — oblige farmers to protect the environment if they want public money.

Advertisement

The Commission took mere weeks to draft the proposal, working at the behest of national authorities and consulting only with farmers who are subject to the rules. It did not perform an impact assessment — a gold standard for quality legislation, according to its own rulebook — nor did it talk to civil society groups representing the interests of the broader public.

GET FULL ACCESS