Trump’s tariffs give Democrats an opening. Will they take it?

By Daniel Desrochers | 03/13/2025 01:23 PM EDT

Democrats are trying to pull off a balancing act on trade as they try to win back Rust Belt voters.

Jeff Ware, president of Resurgence Brewing Company, poses for a portrait near a stockpile of aluminum cans, which are sourced from Canada, Thursday, Feb. 27, 2025, in Buffalo, N.Y.

Jeff Ware, president of Resurgence Brewing, poses for a portrait near a stockpile of aluminum cans, which are sourced from Canada, on Feb. 27 in Buffalo, New York. Lauren Petracca/AP

President Donald Trump’s slash-and-burn approach to trade policy has given Democrats an opening. They’re just not sure how to seize it.

Nowhere is their conflicted response more evident than in the upper Midwest, where Trump’s new tariffs on Canada, Mexico, China and other major trading partners promise both possible upsides but also tremendous risks for automakers and other manufacturers that are central to the regional economy.

Democrats from states like Michigan and Pennsylvania are trying to thread the needle by condemning Trump’s erratic policy pronouncements and attacks on allies like Canada, while not criticizing tariffs or protectionist policies.

Advertisement

“It’s indiscriminate tariffs that are not based on anything — that’s the problem,” said Sen. Gary Peters (D-Mich.) “I’ve supported tariffs. I supported Joe Biden’s 100 percent tariff on electric vehicles from China.”

GET FULL ACCESS