Virginia Supreme Court rejects youth climate case

By Lesley Clark | 02/27/2025 06:15 AM EST

Young activists in Virginia had sought to make the case that state energy policies are hurting them by worsening the effects of climate change.

Two children play in the mud outside their Whitewood, Virginia, home, which was damaged by a 2022 flash flood.

Two children play in the mud outside their Whitewood, Virginia, home, which was damaged by a 2022 flash flood. Michael Clubb/AP

The Virginia Supreme Court has declined to revive a youth-led lawsuit that claimed the state’s permitting of fossil fuels violates the constitutional rights of young people by worsening the effects of climate change.

In a brief order issued Tuesday, the court said it was “of the opinion” that the Virginia Court of Appeals had made “no reversible error” when it dismissed Layla H. v. Commonwealth of Virginia. The appeals court in 2024 had found that the youth had not demonstrated injuries that were particular to them.

The high court held oral arguments in the case Feb. 11 and appeared skeptical the challengers could prevail.

Advertisement

Nate Bellinger, lead attorney for the young people, said in a statement that the decision shows a “troubling misunderstanding of the law and the serious constitutional and public trust issues at hand.”

GET FULL ACCESS