Why Trump’s coal revival may be short-lived

By Benjamin Storrow | 09/30/2025 06:18 AM EDT

The administration’s plan to boost coal may provide modest relief to existing plants but likely won’t prompt new investment, analysts say.

The Warrick Power Plant operates in Newburgh, Indiana.

The Warrick Power Plant operates in Newburgh, Indiana. Joshua A. Bickel/AP

It’s “take two” for the Trump coal rescue.

President Donald Trump sought to rectify one of his first-term policy failures by announcing a sprawling plan Monday to bring back coal. But industry analysts say that rolling back pollution regulations, expanding mining leases and offering government investment can only provide short-term relief to an industry in decline. Coal’s fundamental problem is that coal-burning power plants are aging and that American utilities aren’t building new ones.

“It maybe kicks the can down the road a little longer,” said Tony Knutson, who leads coal research at the consultancy Wood Mackenzie. “It’s a bit of a lifeline. I wouldn’t call it a resurrection or a return to a golden age or anything like that.”

Advertisement

Trump was largely powerless to stop a wave of coal plant retirements during his first four years in the White House, when weak power demand and cheap natural gas undermined his campaign pledge to revive the industry.

GET FULL ACCESS