Tensions flare over ‘most important fish’ in the ocean

By Daniel Cusick | 12/03/2025 01:09 PM EST

Sportfishing and environmental groups say tougher regulations are urgently needed for commercial catch of menhaden, a small species crucial to ecosystems along the Atlantic Ocean and Gulf Coast.

A fisherman looks down at a school of menhaden caught in a net off the coast of Smith Island in Virginia.

A fisherman looks down at a school of menhaden caught in a net off the coast of Smith Island in Virginia on June 22, 2015. Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/AFP via Getty Images

A small ocean fish with silvery skin and oily flesh has retaken center stage in a long-running debate over fishing and ecosystem health in two of the nation’s most productive estuaries: the Chesapeake Bay and Louisiana’s Gulf Coast.

Sport fishermen and environmentalists are again demanding that regulators do more to protect menhaden (pronounced men-HAY-den), a fish once so abundant it helped sustain entire ocean food chains — gobbled up by everything from Atlantic striped bass to Gulf of Mexico red drum.

Increasingly, however, advocates say menhaden are showing signs of stress in their core habitats, a condition some attribute to commercial fishing pressure in the lower Chesapeake Bay and along Louisiana’s brackish coast. A decline of menhaden in either region would mean more than another lost species for commercial and recreational fishermen. As with other forage fish like herring and shad, menhaden are central to the greater ocean ecosystem, providing sustenance for higher-order fish that fetch premium prices at seafood counters and restaurants.

Advertisement

The diminutive species was christened “the most important fish in the sea” by Rutgers University historian H. Bruce Franklin in a 2007 book of the same name, a status it still claims two decades later.

GET FULL ACCESS